The Contractor Bid Came In 40% Over. Now What?
Three bids on the same scope should not vary by half. When they do, the scope is the problem, not the contractor — and the fix is line items.
You budgeted $60,000. The bid says $84,000. Before you decide the contractor is expensive, get two more bids — because the second number tells you almost nothing on its own, and the spread between three tells you almost everything.
A wide spread is a scope problem, not a price problem
Worked example (hypothetical). Three bids on what you believed was the same job:
- Contractor A: $84,000
- Contractor B: $61,000
- Contractor C: $72,000
The spread from low to high is $23,000, which is 38% of the low bid ($23,000 ÷ $61,000). Skilled trades in the same market do not differ in cost by 38%. What differs by 38% is what they each think they were asked to do.
Three bids that far apart are three different jobs wearing the same address.
Normalize before you compare
Put the bids side by side as line items and find what one includes that another does not. On this job, suppose the comparison turns up:
- A includes a full electrical rewire — $14,000. B and C priced replacing devices and the panel only.
- B excludes permits — $2,400 — and excludes dumpsters and haul-off, about $3,000.
- C priced a mid-tier cabinet package; A and B priced builder-grade.
Strip everything to a common scope:
- A: $84,000 − $14,000 = $70,000
- B: $61,000 + $2,400 + $3,000 = $66,400
- C: $72,000
Now the spread is $5,600, which is 8.4% of the low bid ($5,600 ÷ $66,400). That is a real bid spread — the normal difference between three competent contractors with different overhead and different appetite for your job.
Everything that looked like a pricing disaster was a specification failure, and the specification is yours.
The $14,000 question is yours to answer
Notice what the normalization surfaced: one contractor thinks this house needs a full rewire and two do not. That is not a bid dispute. It is a scope decision worth $14,000, and it belongs to you, not to whoever bid it.
Answering it is a specific task: get the panel and wiring inspected by someone with no bid on the job, find out whether it is knob-and-tube or aluminum branch wiring, and check what the local inspector will require once you pull a permit for the work you are doing. Then decide — and re-bid on the answer.
The worst outcome is picking Contractor B because they are cheapest, discovering the rewire is mandatory in month two, and paying for it as a change order at change-order pricing.
What to do before the next bid
Write the scope yourself, room by room, before anyone walks the house. Every fixture, every finish level, every "remove and replace" versus "repair." A contractor bidding your written scope is answering your question. A contractor bidding "make this rentable" is answering their own.
Say explicitly what is included. Permits, dumpsters, haul-off, port-a-john, final clean, dump fees, and who buys materials. These are the lines that create phantom spreads, and every one of them is a real cost that someone pays.
Require line items, not a lump sum. A single number cannot be compared, cannot be negotiated in the one place it is wrong, and cannot be checked against the draw schedule later. A bid you cannot compare row by row is a bid you cannot evaluate.
Ask what is excluded and get it in writing. The exclusions list is where the surprises live, and a good contractor will have one ready.
And if the bids are genuinely all high
Sometimes you normalize, the spread tightens, and every number is still well over your budget. Then the finding is real, and there are only four honest responses:
- Your estimate was wrong — usually because it came from a per-square-foot rate rather than the systems you are actually touching
- The scope is too rich for the ARV; cut finish level, not structure
- The market is tight and trades are pricing accordingly, which is a real input to every deal you underwrite this quarter
- The deal does not work at a rehab number that is now $24,000 higher — so re-run the maximum allowable offer and see whether it survives
The fourth is the one people skip. A rehab number that moved is not a construction problem to be managed. It is an input change, and it should flow straight back into what you can pay.
Frequently asked questions
Why do contractor bids vary so much?
Almost always because they are pricing different scopes — different inclusions, different finish levels, different assumptions about what is behind the walls. Normalize to a common scope and most of the spread disappears.
How many bids should I get on a rehab?
Three is the standard, and the reason is that two bids cannot tell you which one is the outlier. The value is in the comparison, not in the lowest number.
Should I always take the lowest bid?
No. Take the lowest bid on the correct scope, from someone who can actually start when you need them. A low bid that excludes required work is the most expensive kind.
What should a rehab bid include?
Line items by room or system, labour and materials identified, permits and dumpsters stated as included or excluded, a start date, a duration, and a written exclusions list.
What if the rehab number changes after I am under contract?
Re-run your maximum allowable offer with the new number. If the deal no longer works, that is what your inspection period is for — renegotiate or walk, before the number becomes a problem you own.
MAOnow computes maximum allowable offer, multi-source ARV, itemized rehab, rental DSCR and construction draw economics, then exports a lender-ready PDF. Free forever, no card. Built by an FMVA-certified modeler with a decade at S&P Global.
Run the Numbers Free →MAOnow is analysis software — not an appraiser, attorney, accountant or lender, and not a promise of any outcome. Worked examples use hypothetical figures with the arithmetic shown; your market decides your numbers.